Draft Afterword (I)

1 Jul

Comments would be welcome


The story of Cincinnatus (Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus (519 – 430 BC) is one of those stories that resonate down the ages. Put simply, Cincinnatus was a Roman politician and military leader (the Romans didn’t consider the two separate spheres) who was appointed Dictator when the Roman Republic faced a potentially fatal threat from a barbarian tribe. Cincinnatus took command, built an army, defeated the barbarians and returned to his farm, all within fifteen days. As such, he is generally considered a model of civic virtue.

However, his story needs to be placed in context.

The Romans were very suspicious of anyone who sought too much power, to the point where anyone who seemed to be too powerful or too popular would be dragged down by the rest of the politicians. Accordingly, they appointed two Heads of State (the Consuls) who would serve for a year, a system that ensured that the two men would watch each other carefully for signs of undue ambition as well as actually running the government. The system was, in many ways, dangerously unstable. A man who felt himself slighted unfairly by the Senate – like Julius Caesar – might go into open rebellion against the might of Rome.

This was not a system that encouraged single-mindedness. The Romans, recognising that this was a major problem when the state was under attack, created the office of Dictator. These men were granted absolute power for a fixed period, then expected to shuffle off into the sidelines of history. They were, among other things, spared the threat of criminal prosecution for anything they did while in power. (It is a curious testament to the system that Sulla, who had taken the post by force, was never killed by one of his many enemies after he returned power to the Senate.) The Roman Dictators were never meant to remain in power indefinitely, unlike modern-day dictators.

And yet, so many people have drawn the wrong lesson from the story of Cincinnatus.

There is a curious agreement among thinkers from both the Left and the Right, although both of them would be horrified by the suggestion that they might have something in common. The Far Right does not object to the concept of an absolute dictator, per se; they expect only that the dictator be a good and virtuous man. Thus, the concentration of unchecked, unbalanced and fundamentally unaccountable power is only a problem if held by a man they do not consider to be a good man. They do not expect the good man to become sullied by the power he holds.

Human history would tend to suggest otherwise. Men of high ideals, good and decent men, have made successful grabs for power, then become corrupted and brought low by their success. Anything larger than a tiny business with a handful of employees cannot be micromanaged by a single person effectively, much less a whole country. Hiccups breed frustration. Dissent and disagreement becomes treachery. All who dare to speak out are crushed mercilessly. Each wave of repression brings on the next wave of repression. And then all life is drained out of the system.

The Romans knew the dangers of granting one man absolute power indefinitely. Those who admire the Roman Republic have not learned the lessons of its fall.

But the Far Left, if anything, has a worse problem. This is the concept of government by party. Instead of a single personage, all power is vested in the hands of the ruling body, often the Communist Party. In Russia, they talked of passing all power to the Soviets, then to the Bolsheviks. But when the Bolsheviks took control, the results were, if anything, even worse than the Tsars.

A living dictator can show empathy – or outright sadism. But a bureaucracy, governed by a committee, can be a great deal worse. In the interests of imposing communism, the Bolsheviks starved, slaughtered and crushed independent peasant farmers right across the Soviet Union. They were so intent on imposing their will that they chose to ignore the simple fact that they were crippling their country’s ability to produce food, ensuring that Russia would eventually have to buy food from the United States. The committee believed it could determine everything, despite being far more detached from the population than any single dictator, and ruined Russia’s ability to create a modern economy.

Both of these examples illustrate the true danger, the willingness to allow power to be concentrated in a single set of hands. Anyone who has done battle with the bureaucracy in just about any country will know how hard it is to get them to admit to a mistake. The people you deal with will either be unable or unwilling to help you. This may not be their fault. A bureaucracy that is trying to run the country will be huge, so huge that the people on the front lines will have no real authority of their own. But the bureaucracy will have no tolerance for its servants who fail to do exactly as they are told. Common sense will take a walk when they are forced to toe the line or get fired. Hence we have problems when a bureaucracy takes a child from his or her parents because that is what the regulations say they have to do, even if common sense says otherwise.

But human nature overshadows both the Dictator and the Committee. They will be tempted – very tempted – to use their absolute power for their own good, not for that of their people. Both will give the best jobs to their relatives, confusing themselves with the state, while milking everything they can from their positions. The Soviet Union was littered with dachas that belonged to Party Officials, each one built from public funds, yet denied to the public.

With all of this in mind, why would someone want to give a person – or a committee – absolute power?

22 Responses to “Draft Afterword (I)”

  1. wraiththirteen July 1, 2014 at 3:43 pm #

    First of all I consider Ron Paul to be the definition of the far right simply because he wants to get government smaller. Everyone else is a lefty either a moral lefty or immoral lefty. But then it is politically expedient for me to say the right is for smaller government (hopefully if I say it long enough and loud enough the rest of the right will make it happen, and give a bunch of federal bureaucrats their pink slips and I mean in the hundreds of thousands and yes america has that many bureaucrats something like over a million working for the federal government)
    That said to answer your question sometimes you give someone absolute power because you fear the enemy, rome did this several times before Cesare became emperor. The one that I always find fascinating is the general who killed 1 in 10 of his army because they retreated, and they stood their and took that.
    Then of course you got the people who were conquered and they had their freedom stripped away although eventually these people fought for it back.
    Then you have comunism which more often than not promised a bunch of kids friggin utopia if they brought communism to their countries. Give up your freedoms and you will be rich. Do you realize cuba was one of if not the most developed country out of the gulf of mexico islands when castro took over and now everything there is rotting?
    then of course you have the serfs of the middle ages who never had freedom to begin with who had to work like dogs otherwise they would starve. For them it was either freedom or starvation.

  2. David Matthewson July 1, 2014 at 3:54 pm #

    Chris – neatly said. Thanks!

  3. Paul (Drak Bibliophile) Howard July 1, 2014 at 4:46 pm #

    To quote James Madison “If men were Angels, we’d need no government. If Angels were to govern us, government would need no limits”.

    The Founders of the US understood this but American Liberals imagine that they are the Angels.

  4. Dedra July 28, 2014 at 3:34 pm #

    If you’re one of those people, it may sound ironic,
    but your choice of place to stay may be a challenging endeavor.
    In Bangkok and Chiang Mai, for instance, you can book a 4 star
    hotel for less than $50 a night if you are willing to be five or ten minutes away from the center of town. Do a little research to explore the many more fine choices of
    hotels in Bukit Bintang has to offer.

  5. peixoto flamingo bikini July 31, 2014 at 9:42 pm #

    With so much variety in the market – whether you’re looking for your kids’ favorite cartoon characters or something sporty with racing
    stripes, you’ll be able to find exactly what you’re looking for.

    But when an old favorite serves it’s purpose so simply and perfectly,
    many retro-inspired swimmers don’t feel the need to constantly update
    their style. February 27 – March 1, 2011 – JA New York Winter Show:.

  6. Marianne August 3, 2014 at 11:56 am #

    “There’s just a tremendous amount of demand for therapeutic massage,” Kim explains, “people are looking for alternatives
    to painkillers people are turning to more holistic approaches these days.
    By being aware that the truth is not simple for most health issues, the tendency
    to oversimplify and over generalize health information can be thwarted.
    Housing homes are in big need real estate turkey in addition to commercial residential property.

  7. tigari electronice ego August 5, 2014 at 11:24 am #

    There are many types of gifts that can be given for Father’s Day.

    ‘ Clear backpacks: These are most suitable for kids attending different grades at school.
    A susceptible gift can give you your desired aspirations
    or even more.

  8. tigari electronice ieftine August 6, 2014 at 5:24 am #

    What if you don’t KNOW what the gift receiver likes. So this is why I will be bulk buying some velvet cushions and anything else I happen to notice that is nice and on offer, as.
    The Honey Baked Ham Company offers both hams and turkeys that will feed
    a dinner party.

  9. http://haridasrvhatkar.com/ August 8, 2014 at 4:50 pm #

    As you are shopping for your travel golf bag, you will
    need to compare the amenities that you need
    as opposed to what you want. Conventional travel agencies still command a
    large portion of the travel booking industry.
    different companies give you their estimates over the phone.

  10. Singapore holding company formation August 8, 2014 at 5:44 pm #

    But Mike Warburton, tax partner at Grant Thornton, says this doesn’t mean that
    higher earners should immediately pay more into their pensions.

    Unless we change with it, we will find our clients leaving in droves.
    With the strength of experienced charted accountants and cost accountants this firm is like the most preferred brand
    in this field.

  11. browning bolt August 9, 2014 at 4:01 am #

    Ƭhanks to my father who stated to me ߋn the toƿic of this weblog, this blog is genuinely remarkable.

  12. Lakeisha August 10, 2014 at 1:14 am #

    If you would like to check your inventory status, then letter E comes into use.
    The first thing which can be done to enhance the graphical quality of
    the cool Minecraft seeds is by increasing the resolution. The individual that rents or buys the server from the gaming host can then advertise people to
    join on their server.

  13. Caryn August 10, 2014 at 7:22 pm #

    You have so much to learn, and even if you have been trying for
    two or three years, you still have so much to learn. This is exactly where you find the work at online home jobs dropping out of
    helping hand. If you’re not spending a huge amount of your time your profit margin could rise considerably and leave your account too expensive; remember you will also
    have to contend with the prices that other gamers are offering.

  14. electronic cigarette ego-t August 10, 2014 at 7:49 pm #

    Obviously there are no guarantees of getting it right the first time but the more
    you know about a brand the more likely you are to get it right the first time.
    I am addict for the last 25 years and smoking is what I do first
    thing in morning and last in the evening but when every I tried to quit
    and had a little success for a couple of weeks, I never suffered
    from withdrawal symptoms. Simply lighting a cigarette can require a driver’s hands to be taken from the steering wheel, and cause the driver to look away from the

  15. ways to make money eaily by phone August 10, 2014 at 7:56 pm #

    On site SEO to make money online always starts with keyword research.

    The best designed and cleanly laid out sites were much talked about.
    The company gives me $10 for every new customer that uses the coupon.

  16. UK Soccer August 12, 2014 at 12:56 am #

    This community lets you share POI locations and information or interact with other site members.
    Fulham FC – Craven Cottage – Craven Cottage is the home
    ground of Fulham FC. With The European Union as well as China, footballs had been made from k9

  17. Fidelia August 13, 2014 at 6:39 am #

    Some research has been conducted on the effectiveness or safeness of several treatments to validate claims
    of companies who produce male enhancement products or programs.
    The main purpose of penis enlargement pump is to help in erectile dysfunction so that you can get the desired erection and maintain it.
    Here you will find the real picture of Natural Penis Enhancement Product and their real
    natural ingredients info.

  18. Buy Twitter followers August 29, 2014 at 9:17 am #

    Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my apple ipad and tested to
    see if it can survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad
    is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is entirely off topic but
    I had to share it with someone!

  19. cialis September 2, 2014 at 7:41 am #

    Hello there! Do you know if they make any plugins to protect against hackers?
    I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any tips?

  20. Aloe Vera cleanse September 12, 2014 at 8:28 pm #

    Hey! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be okay.
    I’m definitely enjoying your blog and look forward to new posts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: